
Hi friends! 🍂 It’s been a little while since I introduced the blind date with a book concept on the blog, but I thought I’d get back to it this week with a special fall edition!
If you’re not familiar with the blind date with a book concept, it’s simple: you pick a book, based on some key words such as tropes, settings… and then, you discover the book.
I hope you’ll enjoy the idea and please, let me know if you want more posts like this one! ☀️
Happy reading, friends!

Blind Date With an Underrated YA Book: Take Your Pick!
Read all the little descriptions (on the images, transcripted below as well) and pick the one that you’re drawn to, the most. Click on it and you’ll be taken to the book of your choice ✨






- Book 1 : boarding school setting, ghosts, family mystery, squad goals, forbidden romance, atmospheric, twists & turns
- Book 2 : college setting, anxiety rep, great friendships, ex friends turned enemies turned roomies, just adorably relatable
- Book 3 : childhood best friends, angst and emotions, alternating between past and present, about love, family, home
- Book 4 : in the future, about climate change & overwhelming corporate negligence, plants growing from people’s skin, mixed media, hopeful
- Book 5 : complex, intense girl friendship, deadly fire, twisted, addictive mystery, multiple POV, told between past & present
- Book 6 : mystery, two timelines, about loss & grieving, academic rivals, poignant and emotional, about the fierce love you can have for someone you love & lost

The Underrated YA Books I Recommend
Book 1

The Library of Shadows, Rachel Moore
Este doesn’t believe in ghosts when she enrolls at Radcliffe prep, a boarding school notorious for its student disappearances. All she wants is to go to the same school as her father and figure out who he was. That is until she meets Mateo, an actual ghost and he frames her for stealing a rare book…
I had so much fun reading this YA fantasy, I really enjoyed the library setting, the banter, the relationships and the atmosphere overall. A perfect fall read!
Find on Goodreads ☂️ Buy on: Amazon – Bookshop – Blackwell’s

Book 2
Unnecessary Drama, Nina Kenwood
Brooke’s starting her first year of college and moving in with two other roomates… one of them being her former childhood best friend/high school nemesis.
I absolutely adored this book, a quiet YA contemporary gem that just nails what it’s like to start college, independance as a young adult and it has this excellent anxiety rep I’m still crying about. It’s adorable and extraordinary and just read it please.
Find on Goodreads ☂️ Buy on: Amazon – Bookshop – Blackwell’s


Book 3

Some Mistakes Were Made, Kristin Dwyer
Ellis and Eaton have been inseparable since childhood… until Ellis’s forced to move out halfway across the country. She comes back after a year apart…
Honestly, if you love YA contemporary books with childhood friends, tons of angst and emotions, you will love this one. It’s the kind of book you want to read under a warm blanket and cry about, afterwards.
Find on Goodreads ☂️ Buy on: Amazon – Bookshop – Blackwell’s

Book 4
Green Rising, Lauren James
This book is set in a future on the brink of an ecological catastrophe. We follow three teenagers in this complex world, where teenagers develop strange abilities: grow plants from their own skin.
Lauren James has an incredible mind and this book is so, so unique. Deeply echoing with out current world’s issues, it’s also hopeful, addictive and really imaginative.
Add to Goodreads ☂️ Buy on: Amazon – Bookshop – Blackwell’s


Book 5

All The Best Liars, Amelia Kahaney
Three girls, three best friends since childhood… until they grow apart and then, one of them dies in a deadly fire. What happened to them, really?
This YA mystery blew my mind. Now that I think about it again, I just loved it SO much. It’s thrilling, mysterious and kept me on edge the whole time. A perfect read if you’re loving mysteries in the fall season!
Find on Goodreads ☂️ Buy on: Amazon – Bookshop – Blackwell’s

Book 6
All That’s Left To Say, Emery Lord
Sophie died of an overdose a year ago… but Hannah still doesn’t believe it. Determined to get to the bottom of what really happened to her cousin and her best friend, Hannah enrolls in her posh high school and starts investigating…
Loved this synopsis, loved this intense, poignant story dealing with grief, with a bit of mystery and a side of academic rivals to something. Definitely a gem.
Find on Goodreads ☂️ Buy on: Amazon – Bookshop – Blackwell’s


Enjoyed this list? See a book you’d like to read? Order them through these retailers below and support our work. No extra fees and a brand new book for you, a little help for us. Thank you!
For more YA book recommendations, check out these blog posts:
- 12 Great YA Books To Read Based On Your Favorite Season
- Pick a Fall Aesthetic & Get a YA Book Recommendation!
- 10 Cozy YA Books To Read For Fall
📌 Pin Blind date with a YA book, fall edition on Pinterest!



What book did you pick? Do you feel like reading it?
Do you like this kind of blog post idea? I’d love to hear your thoughts in comments!

Twitter ☂️ Bookstagram ☂️Goodreads ☂️ Bloglovin’ ☂️ Support the blog
Subscribe to the newsletter for more book recommendations, exclusive intl giveaways, behind the scenes and more:
This is so fun and of course I went with book one as soon as I saw board school setting!
Boarding school settings are always the beeest!! Thank you so much for stopping by, Kristin! <3
These have been some of my favorite posts of yours! I chose book 2, which means I’ll definitely have to check it out (even though I did check to make sure all of the other books are on my TBR). Great post xxx
Melina | http://www.melinaelisa.com
Aww thank you so much, this means so much! 🙂
OH MY GOSH!!!! THIS IS SUCH A UNIQUE CONCEPT IM HONEST TO GOODNESS OBSESSED?? also all the books sound so good!!! im genuinely confused about how ive never heard of the library of shadows because WOW IT SOUNDS PERFECT. (ghosts in school settings is everything ive ever wanted okay) all that’s left to say looks painful SO GIMME.
Oh thank you so much, so happy you enjoyed this post!! ❤️ I hope you’ll get a chance to read Library of Shadows soon, it was EXCELLENT! ❤️
I love this post concept! 🥰 I have seen Green Rising around before but this is the first time it has got my attention! I should do blind dates more often 😁
Ahhh thank you! I hope you’ll give it a try, it was such a unique read! 😀
I enjoyed Kenwood’s book, too, but Some Mistakes Were Made – MY HEART! So, good.
I loved this book so much, so many emotions ❤️ I can’t WAIT to read her next one!!
this is such a nice idea! loved this post❤️
Aww thank you so, so much, so happy you enjoyed it! ❤️
I love your Blind Date with a Book posts so much! ❤️ The Library of Shadoes is on top of my TBR at the moment – I don’t think I’ll be able to finish it in October, but hopefully next month 😊 I’ve also been meaning to read Unnecessary Drama, as I loved Nina Kenwood’s debut so much 🥰
Oh thank you so, so much, Caro, this means so much <3 I can't WAIT for you to read Nina Kenwood's book, you'd love it so much! <3
This is such a fun post idea – I haven’t read any of your choices, but you convinced me with your description of the Emery Lord book!
Ahh thank you so much, Nicole! I hope you’ll enjoy it if you ever read it! <3
I love these types of posts so much! Library of Shadows has been on my will-I-buy-it-or-won’t-I-list ever since I first heard of it, I think this might be my sign to get it 🙂
Ohh yay! I hope you’ll love it 🙂